Myers began their professional career in 2011 as a receiving supervisor at Red Rocket Merchandising. In 2013, they transitioned to Shop Rite of Clinton as an assistant bookkeeper. Two years later, they joined Webster Bank as a universal banker. Myers was promoted to senior universal banker in 2017 and then to assistant banking center manager in 2018. Andrea left Webster Bank in 2020 to join Ruoff Mortgage as an express underwriter. In 2021, they were promoted to operations management assistant. Myers is currently an advisor at Senior Benefit Services.